Найдено 41
Post-COVID-19 Era Forensics: Hospital Autopsies, New Methodologies, and Medicolegal Perspectives
Zaami S., Napoletano G., Marinelli E., Sablone S., De Paola L., Introna F.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2025, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: Hospital autopsies, once considered fundamental to evidence-based medicine, have declined in many Western countries due to legislative changes, faith-based objections, and inadequate funding in public healthcare. However, the COVID-19 pandemic has revitalized interest in their importance for determining the cause of death and generating public health statistics. This study analyzes the factors contributing to this decline, with a focus on the Italian context and the new medicolegal perspectives arising in the post-pandemic era. Methods: The research was conducted through an analysis of 91 relevant scientific sources, including government documents, policy briefs, and academic studies. Legislative and regulatory factors influencing the reduction in hospital autopsies were examined, along with new technological and medicolegal perspectives that have emerged following the COVID-19 pandemic. Special attention was given to the Italian context and the pandemic’s impact on autopsy practices. Results: The analysis revealed that the perceived “low value” of autopsies often stems from technological advancements, which have led to the view of these procedures as redundant. However, in the post-COVID-19 era, there has been a renewed awareness of the medicolegal value of autopsies, with significant implications for public health statistics and the evolution of forensic medicine. Conclusions: The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the vital role of autopsies in delivering accurate medical information, prompting renewed attention to these procedures in the post-pandemic era. Moving forward, hospital autopsies will need to balance technological innovations with traditional medicolegal practices, paving the way for new perspectives in forensic medicine and public health data management.
A Rare Case of Small Vessel Vasculitis in Fatal Promazine Intoxication: The Synergy of Adverse Events Resulting in Death
Tatriele N., Giorato G., Baldisser F., Turrini R., Brunelli M., Ausania F., Pigaiani N.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2025, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: Nowadays, exotoxic substance intake is among the most frequently employed methods of suicide. Self-poisoning is quite common among psychiatric patients treated in hospitals. Psychotropic drugs used for suicide include phenothiazines. Promazine hydrochloride (Talofen©) is an alpha-lytic phenothiazine neuroleptic with a high affinity for histaminergic H1 receptors and a low affinity for dopaminergic D2, serotoninergic 5-HT, alpha1-adrenergic, and muscarinic receptors, which may explain its potent sedative effect. The most common adverse effects include extrapyramidal syndromes, weight gain, orthostatic hypotension, QTc prolongation, convulsions, delirium, and psychosis. Rare adverse events include the potential occurrence of autoimmune syndromes and vasculitis. Methods: We report herein the delayed death of a 59-year-old woman due to cardiocirculatory arrest on an arrhythmic basis in the context of vasculitis of the small pulmonary vessels and prolongation of the QTc interval secondary to voluntary acute intoxication with promazine hydrochloride. Results: The incident occurred in a psychiatric patient with a history of prior self-harming acts. Histological investigations revealed wavy fibers in the heart, a lymphocytic granulocyte infiltrate in the walls of small- and medium-caliber vessels, and spotty perivascular deposition of histiocyte-macrophage cells in the lungs. Immunophenotypic investigations showed the prevalence of CD15+ and T-CD3+ elements, thus identifying a small vessel vasculitis. These findings were consistent with the literature regarding adverse events following the intake of promazine hydrochloride, although vasculitis is rare. Conclusions: Thus, while QTc lengthening and arrhythmic incidents are widely reported events associated with promazine hydrochloride use, the development of a rare condition such as pulmonary vasculitis undoubtedly played a synergistic and decisive stressogenic role in the genesis of the cardiac event, leading to irreversible functional arrest.
Validity of the Rapid Nasopharyngeal Antigen Swab for the Detection of SARS-CoV-2 on Cadavers
Caristo I., Barranco R., Lo Pinto S., Ventura F.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2025, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: SARS-CoV-2 is classified as a class 3 biological agent; therefore, autopsies on positive subjects must be performed in BSL 3 sectorial rooms. However, many centers lacking such facilities perform molecular nasopharyngeal swabs for SARS-CoV-2 on corpses before autopsy. This approach, though, is marked by prolonged reporting times and extremely high costs. This study aims to compare the results of molecular swabs (RT-PCR) with rapid antigen swabs (RAT) in order to assess if RAT can serve as the sole test for determining corpse positivity or negativity. Methods: Sixty corpses with positive molecular nasopharyngeal swabs for SARS-CoV-2, performed either ante-mortem or post-mortem, were selected. Afterward, they underwent rapid antigen swabs within 0 to 11 days after the last molecular exam. Results: Out of 60 corpses with positive molecular swabs, 52 antigen swabs were positive (86.67%), and 8 were negative (13.33%), indicating a sensitivity of 86.66% and specificity of 100%. Conclusions: Considering the sensitivity and specificity values observed in this study, RAT could be used as the primary investigation on corpses, especially in centers that lack BSL 3 sectorial rooms. Molecular swabs could then serve as a secondary test for subjects negative on RAT.
Formal Relationship Between the Firearm “Memory Effect” and the Decay Time of the GSR Particles Present on the Shooter’s Hands
Nunziata C., Rotter G., Nunziata F.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2025, цитирований: 1,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background/Objectives: The Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM), combined with an Energy Dispersive Spectrometer (EDS), has been, for over fifty years of practical experience and research in the field, the analytical system of choice for the investigation and analysis of Gun Shot Residues (GSRs). However, the interpretation of analytical results has profoundly changed in recent decades. Specifically, the criteria for evaluating particles presumptive of contamination of a possible discharge have evolved, assessments regarding possible primary/secondary transfer phenomena have been refined, and the retention times of particulate matter on various types of surfaces involved during the discharge have been revalued. The purpose of this study is to provide a formal representation that links together the firearm memory effect, namely the formation of composite characteristic GSRs resulting from the use of the same Firearm but with ammunition having different metallic alloy constituents and different primer mixtures, and the decay time. Methods: The deduced mathematical model is based on experimental results reported in the scientific literature listed below, and it has been elaborated with a series of non-contradictory assumptions, each of which plays a specific role in the mathematical formalism used. Results and Conclusions: This model, although not yet validated through rigorous experimentation, represents a valuable tool in investigations related to the firearm memory effect when forensic specialists have collected GSR samples from the hands of the alleged shooter within four hours of the shooting.
Strangulation Using Cable Ties and a Suicidal Manner of Death: A Case Report and Literature Review Addressing an Atypical Suicidal Mode
Cecannecchia C., De Simone S., Baldari B., Cipolloni L., Cioffi A.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
Обзор, PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: Strangulation by ligature, most frequently employed for homicidal purposes, is not a common suicide method. Even more infrequent is the use by the victim of cable ties as a tool of self-strangulation. Methods: We describe a case of a 50-year-old woman who was found dead with a cable tie tight around her neck. In our case, analysis of the circumstantial data and the psychopathological history of the victim—along with an external examination, an autopsy, and toxicological findings—was crucial in the differential diagnosis between death intentionally inflicted by a third person and suicide. Through a narrative review conducted by performing a literature search using online resources (PubMed, Google Scholar, and ScienceDirect). Results: we were only able to identify eight similar cases. Conclusions: These were compared with our case, to trace similarities and differences, useful in guiding the forensic doctor in the diagnosis of death in such circumstances.
Subsampling Blood Swabs as an Efficient and Good Practice for RapidHIT ID® Analyses
Siatka C., Privat L., Franzoni A., Rosso M., Hubac S., Hermitte F.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background/Objectives: Rapid DNA instruments are gaining interest in the forensic community as a means of generating DNA profile information more quickly than standard laboratory workflows, and they have the potential to be carried out in decentralized structures of the main laboratory, such as in French overseas territories, where no laboratory facilities are installed. Although this system has been shown to be effective in analyzing rich traces (such as blood) sampled on a swab, it has the disadvantage of consuming the entire swab for analysis. Since it is impossible to double the sampling from very few blood stains, we designed a subsampling protocol of the main swab for analysis on RapidHIT ID® instruments. Methods: Two volumes of blood (10 µL and 150 µL) from four individuals were applied to a regular Copan flocked swab and then subsampled by three different operators using a Copan mini (subungual) flocked swab to recover a portion of the biological material. Results:The analysis of the mini swabs allows us to obtain a complete genetic profile regardless of the initial volume, with a better genetic profile intensity associated with a higher initial volume deposited on the regular swab. Conclusions: Therefore, this study presents a novel, effective, and adaptable subsampling method that has the potential to significantly improve forensic DNA analysis, particularly in remote or decentralized settings. It offers a flexible solution to current limitations of RapidHIT ID® technology and paves the way for future advancements in genetic forensic science.
Complex Death Associated with Intra-Hospital Adverse Events and SARS-CoV-2 Pneumonia: Court-Appointed Medico-Legal Evaluation
Basile G., Pisano G., Bolcato V., Fassina G., Tronconi L.P.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: Among the deaths recorded during the COVID-19 pandemic, some were caused by clinical manifestations of venous thromboembolic disease, mainly pulmonary embolism. Several litigations were settled worldwide for professional malpractice associated with COVID-19 and anticoagulant therapy management. The authors aimed to discuss, as court-appointed consultants in civil court, a case settled for compensation against a healthcare facility associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection. Case report: We described the case of an old patient in therapy with a direct oral anticoagulant for thrombotic diathesis, hospitalized for COVID-19 pneumonia, who died after two intra-hospital adverse events influencing coagulation imbalance. Discussion: Two health professionals’ malpractice hypotheses were discussed related to the adverse events’ occurrence: one related to the administration of an enema, resulting in rectal perforation, and the other related to proper anticoagulant prophylaxis and comprehensive coagulation imbalance management after the rectal perforation in a patient at high risk of venous thromboembolic disease. Intra-hospital adverse events complicated the hospitalization and then significantly reduced the concrete possibility, even uncertain in terms of time and extent, of the patient’s living longer, representing the damage of reduced possibilities of survival, also called loss-of-chance damage. Conclusions: The case discussed as court advisors, characterized by clinical and legal complexity, together with SARS-CoV-2 infection, underscores the vital role of forensic examiners in cause-of-death ascertainment and as interpreters of statistical-probabilistic data according to naturalistic, logical, and scientific criteria.
Psychological Autopsy: A Powerful Tool in Forensic Investigations
Sablone S., Bellino M., Cardinale A.N., Violante M.G., Risola R., Magno A., Pierro V., Grattagliano I.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: A psychological autopsy is a post-mortem investigative tool used to carry out a retrospective reconstruction of a missing subject’s life. The method includes gathering information from all the potentially involved parties, which may indicate the relevant elements directly or indirectly to trace the victim’s experience and identify personality traits, lifestyle, and interpersonal relationships. Discussion: Psychological autopsies are mainly performed during criminal investigations to identify the cause of death and the specific circumstances (natural, accidental, suicidal, or homicidal death). In addition, from an epidemiological point of view, this method aims to collect the relevant information about an individual’s behavior, circumstances, and reasons for their death to identify common risk factors to prevent new suicides. Although less frequently, this tool can also serve other purposes, such as the legal validity estimation of pre-death actions. Moreover, it may be used to assess whether mistakes have been made in treating people undergoing medical or psychological treatment. Conclusions: Currently, this methodology still has a limited diffusion on the Italian and European scenes due to the lack of standardized guidelines and substantial relevant scientific literature. It is the main factor affecting the tool’s reliability, validity, and systematic application in forensic investigations.
Lessons from the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic: Perspectives in the Medico-Legal Field
Barranco R., Molinelli A., Rocca G., Ventura F.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic led to an enormous global health, social and economic crisis. The pandemic caused considerable upheaval and considerable difficulties due to an unforeseen and devastating health condition. Materials and Methods: We discuss the numerous challenges encountered in the fields of forensic medicine and public health during the COVID-19 pandemic. Particularly during the first wave of the pandemic, forensic pathologists faced significant difficulties due to the lack of safe autopsy protocols and insufficient personal protective equipment. Mainly in Europe, they had to manage a substantial number of potential cases of medical liability related to COVID-19. The widespread outbreak of the virus in residential care homes and prisons posed another significant challenge. Furthermore, forensic pathologists had to address the issue of complications arising from vaccination campaigns. Conclusions: This article underscores the need for continued efforts in scientific research and healthcare preparedness to effectively manage such complex crises. Forensic pathologists must be equipped with the necessary resources and training to address unpredictable, complex situations with far-reaching social implications.
Gunshot Defense Wounds: Three Case Reports and a Literature Review
Ambrosi L., Nicolì S., Ferorelli D., Vaglio R., Solarino B., Benevento M.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
Обзор, PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Defense wounds generally occur when a victim attempts to protect vital organs and blood vessels during an assault, and are therefore typically located on the forearms or hands. Gunshot-induced defense wounds are less frequent compared to stab wounds, which have been extensively described in the literature. We present three cases where victims unsuccessfully attempted to defend themselves from gunshots, and where the detailed description of injuries played a key role in the reconstruction of the crime scenes. In the first case, a man was shot with a smooth-bore shotgun, presenting a “through-and-through” gunshot wound on the lateral surface of the left forearm and a large gaping wound on the posterior surface of the same forearm. The second and third cases involved two men who were shot with handguns. The first displayed an entrance wound on the dorsal surface of the right hand, with burned edges and smoke soiling, and an exit wound on the palmar surface. The second case involved two wounds on the left hand: one on the dorsum and the other on the palm. To the best of our knowledge, few studies in the literature emphasize the role of gunshot defense wounds in aiding the reconstruction of crime dynamics. The cases presented in this study highlight the importance of precisely defining the pathological and morphological features of the wounds, as well as the bullet trajectories, to accurately identify defense wounds. These findings are valuable for reconstructing the dynamics of the assault and providing critical information to the public prosecutor.
Death by Frostbite: From Theory to Reality: A Case Report
Duma S., Mele F., Calvano M., Leonardelli M., Macorano E., De Gabriele G., Cristalli A., Marzullo A., Introna F.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: When the body temperature falls below 35 °C, a condition known as hypothermia occurs. This renders it impossible to regulate the body temperature and produce heat. In these cases, death is due to a cessation of vital functions and is triggered by a body temperature below 25 °C. A multidisciplinary approach is typically required when hypothermia is suspected to combine circumstantial evidence, external examination, autopsy, microscopic and biochemical findings, and other data useful to assess the diagnosis of fatal hypothermia. Post-mortem diagnosis of death by hypothermia frequently presents a medico-legal dilemma. Methods and Results: The authors present a case of hypothermia in which site inspection, autopsy, and histological examination simultaneously revealed the forensic and anatomopathological characteristic findings of hypothermia with some peculiar evidence: paradoxical undressing, thanatochronological phenomena, frost erythema, polyvisceral congestion and Wischnewski spots, and subnuclear vacuolization of renal tubular epithelial cells.
Exploring Cerebrospinal Fluid: Validation of a New Method for Quantification of 39 Drugs of Abuse by LC-MS/MS
Dimitrova A., Croce E.B., Iaquinta G., Ferri E., Faccioli S., Chiavacci G., Gualco B., Focardi M., Grassi S., Vaiano F.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
The use of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in post-mortem (PM) toxicological analysis is an under-addressed topic, likely due to the technical complexity of the collection of a proper sample. However, it is a matrix of significant interest since it has similar chemical and physical properties to the blood and it is less exposed to risks like PM redistribution and diffusion due to its anatomical location. This study aimed to validate a sensitive analytical method for the quantification of drugs of abuse and their metabolites (i.e., cocaine, ketamine, amphetamine, MDPV, 6-monoacetylmorphine, morphine, codeine, and methadone) through liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). CSF was collected through ventricular puncture, and 200 µL was deproteinated with acetonitrile (600 µL). Quantification was carried out, acquiring two MRM transitions for each compound in positive ionization mode. Chromatographic separation was achieved with a C18 column. Limits of quantification ranged from 0.05 to 5 ng/mL. Bias and precision were always within the acceptance criteria. Ion enhancement and suppression effects were observed depending on the substance. The method validated here was applied to a real case, proving to be suitable for PM analysis. CSF and blood were positive for methadone (460 vs. 280 ng/mL), cocaine (125 vs. 69 ng/mL), benzoylecgonine (4640 vs. 3160 ng/mL), and lorazepam (19 vs. 25 ng/mL). In the future, this will be useful for the evaluation of CSF as a valuable alternative matrix in PM investigations.
Clinical, Psychiatric and Medicolegal Issues in Non-Fatal Strangulation: A Case Report
De Paola L., Piersanti V., Tripi D., Marinelli E., Zaami S., Napoletano G.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Introduction: on-fatal strangulation (NFS) is a dangerous mechanism that can produce injuries with varying levels of severity. NFS-related injuries can range from low severity, such as simple contusions, to very severe, with convulsions and major forms of impairment. It is often difficult to gauge the severity of injuries from external and initial manifestations alone; it is therefore necessary to assess the possibility of misdiagnosed injuries or subsequent manifestations. Case report: In this study, we describe the case of a 71-year-old man with several injuries, mainly in the craniofacial region, following an assault by his flatmate. Not only did the subject suffer a concussive head injury and a fracture of the zygomatic bone, but he was also subjected to NFS. The patient was examined three times, and the third examination was carried out directly by us 40 days after the assault. Discussion: We concluded that NFS-related injuries are not always clearly visible and recognized after some time. It would therefore be necessary to standardize the clinical investigation procedure in suspected or confirmed cases of NFS. Conclusion: Clinical investigation should be done from the first hours after the injury event, with the help of forensic experts, with the use of dedicated instrumentation and the acquisition of photographic images, all carried out in a systematic manner for use in court, and a search performed for after-effects that cannot be identified by other methods. Psychological evaluation should also be considered as part of the broader assessment process as victims of NFS often experience significant psychological trauma.
Creation of an Experimental Animal Model for the Study of Postmortem Dark Scleral Spots
Nioi M., Napoli P.E., Nieddu D., Chighine A., Fossarello M., d’Aloja E.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Postmortem dark scleral spots, first described by Sommer in 1833, are well-known in forensic pathology. Background/Objectives: Despite this, their presence is currently considered a nonspecific sign, and their pathogenesis has received little attention in forensic literature. In recent years, however, preliminary studies have suggested new mechanisms in their pathogenesis and links to specific types of death. This study aims to create an experimental model for studying scleral spots. Methods: Twenty sheep, already slaughtered for food, were used. After decapitation, the heads were transported to a room with known temperature and humidity. The right eye underwent eyelid excision, while the left eye’s eyelids were sutured. Continuous observation for approximately 24 h was conducted, with brief interruptions to observe the closed eyes. Results: Dark scleral spots appeared in all open eyes (20/20) after an average of 240.96 ± 58.36 min. The spots did not appear in any of the closed eyes. Conclusions: Experimental data indicate that despite the different location compared to human cadavers, this model serves as an excellent experimental framework for studying postmortem scleral spots.
Iatrogenic Sigma Perforation in a Patient with Localized Rectal and Sigma AL Amyloidosis: A Forensic Case and a Literature Review
Albano G.D., Zerbo S., Di Franco S., Orlando E., Formisano E., Argo A., Belmonte B.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
Обзор, PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Amyloidosis is defined as a rare group of 30 protein-folding diseases characterized by the extracellular deposition of a specific soluble precursor protein that aggregates in the form of insoluble fibrils. The gastrointestinal tract (GI) is a common site for amyloid deposits: Among patients with systemic amyloidosis, at least 70% present with gastrointestinal deposition. Rarely, the deposition is exclusively localized in this area, leading to various gastrointestinal symptoms (bleeding, weight loss, etc.). In this case report, we present a rare and unusual form of localized gastrointestinal amyloidosis, diagnosed after a post-mortem examination of an 83-year-old woman who died due to septic shock resulting from post-colonoscopy iatrogenic perforation of the sigma, in a suspected medical liability case. Morphological examination revealed AL amyloid deposits within the muscular wall of the submucosal vessels of the rectum, which caused increased friability of the vessels and ischemic changes in the intestinal mucosa. A renal cell carcinoma (RCC) was found, which might be related to amyloid deposits, as reported by the literature. Amyloid deposits are an unknown and unpredictable pathological substrate that increase the risk of iatrogenic perforation. Analysis of the medical documentation did not reveal any censurable conduct in terms of prescribing the procedure, technical execution, or subsequent management of the patient following the perforation. GI amyloidosis should be part of the risk stratification of patients with rectal bleeding and gastrointestinal symptoms, and awareness is essential to guide subsequent diagnostic and therapeutic approaches and investigate underlying causes.
Fatal Heat Stroke: A Case Report and Literature Review
Cioffi A., Cecannecchia C., Baldari B., De Simone S., Cipolloni L.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 2,
open access Open access ,
Обзор, PDF, doi.org, Abstract
As known in forensics, heat stroke deaths diagnosis is made by exclusion. In fact, in heat-related deaths, the gross and histologic postmortem findings are not pathognomonic, and biochemical investigations are not specific. Therefore, in such cases, a detailed examination of the circumstantial data and autopsied findings is necessary to exclude other possible causes of death. A case of fatal heat stroke of an elderly woman is reported. This case was diagnosed by examining the above elements in combination with immunohistochemical detection of heat shock proteins (HSPs). We then performed a narrative review of the literature on the subject to compare our case with similar ones. In view of the diagnostic complexity of heat-related deaths, we consider it essential to outline the state of the art on this topic. Our results may be a useful tool to orient forensic investigations into these types of deaths.
Discovering Halite Traces on a Victim’s Clothing through a Forensic Geoscience Analytical Approach: A Suspicious Case in Italy
Lourenço M.D., Di Maggio R.M., Germinario C., Grifa C., Izzo F., Langella A., Mercurio M.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
This suspect case focuses on investigating the presence of halite (NaCl) crystals on the clothing of a deceased individual to determine whether they resulted from immersion in seawater or residual absorption after immersion (i.e., the crystals were left on the clothing after contact with the victim’s wet body). Thirteen clothing samples were collected from various garments worn by the victim and were subjected to optical stereomicroscopy, Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), coupled with Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (EDS), and Simultaneous Thermal Analysis (STA). Optical stereomicroscopy revealed numerous white-colored, vitreous, and greasy luster microcrystals dispersed between fabric fibers, with higher concentrations observed near the hem seams and metal rivets. These microcrystals exhibited predominantly cubic and irregular morphologies. Additionally, sandy particles and organic elements, such as plant fragments and micro seashells, were detected, indicative of coastal environment exposure. SEM-EDS analysis confirmed the presence mainly of sodium and chlorine in stoichiometric ratios consistent with halite, with crystals exhibiting amorphous, needle-shaped, or cubic morphologies. Furthermore, STA analysis identified weight loss events attributed to organic decomposition and halite decomposition at high temperatures, corroborating SEM-EDS findings. The distribution and characteristics of halite crystals, along with other trace elements, support the hypothesis of immersion in seawater while wearing clothing. Specifically, the higher concentrations of halite crystals near thicker fabric portions and metal rivets suggest slower drying rates and longer evaporation times, indicative of immersion rather than residual absorption after swimming. This finding not only helps in determining the victim’s exposure to seawater but also establishes a methodology for distinguishing between different sources of halite residue on clothing. Overall, the comprehensive mineralogical characterization of halite crystals on clothing samples, using best practices of forensic mineralogy, provides valuable forensic insights related to the circumstances that led to the victim’s death. This approach aided investigators in reconstructing the sequence of events, enhancing the accuracy of forensic reconstructions. Moreover, this study contributes to the broader field of forensic geoscience by demonstrating the practical applications of mineralogical analysis in criminal investigations, potentially guiding future research and improving investigative techniques in similar cases.
Forensic Characterisation of Complex Suicides: A Literature Review
Pallocci M., Passalacqua P., Zanovello C., Coppeta L., Ferrari C., Milano F., Gratteri S., Gratteri N., Treglia M.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 2,
open access Open access ,
Обзор, PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Complex suicides refer to using two or more suicide modes. In the literature, complex suicides are distinguished into planned and unplanned. Using multiple methods is related to ensuring a fatal result or because the first method appears too painful, time-consuming, or ineffective. The review aims to provide an overview of the critical features of complex suicides in the forensic context. The review was conducted by searching online databases (PubMed Central and Scopus) up to March 2023. We identified 52 articles that met the inclusion criteria, describing 261 cases. Suicides were classified as planned in 136 cases (52.1%); 105 cases (40.2%) were defined as unplanned, while in the remaining 20 cases (7.7%), the authors did not propose any classification. In 2/261 (0.8%) cases, four modes were indicated, three modes were observed in 34/261 cases (13%), and in 224/261 (85.8%) cases the suicides were carried out using a combination of two distinct methods. The method most frequently employed in the first instance in unplanned suicides were sharp-force injuries and stabbing, followed by mechanical asphyxia (hanging, self-strangulation, plastic bag suffocation) and a fall from height. Regarding planned suicide, the most frequent suicide methods were asphyxia, intoxication (drugs, substances of abuse, or alcohol), and poisoning via toxic substances. Complex suicides represent a relatively rare entity in forensic pathology; nevertheless, they can be challenging for the forensic pathologist in terms of differential diagnosis compared to homicides, due to the sometimes multifaceted presentation.
Violence against Women within Italian and European Context: Italian “Pink Code”—Major Injuries and Forensic Expertise of a Socio-Cultural Problem
De Paola L., Tripi D., Napoletano G., Marinelli E., Montanari Vergallo G., Zaami S.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 2,
open access Open access ,
Обзор, PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Background: Violence against women or other vulnerable individuals is a serious violation of human rights and a global public health issue representing a significant “problem of enormous global health proportions”. Violence against women is an endemic phenomenon; the numbers are very high, highlighting the severity and urgency of the problem. Methods: We conducted this research by examining the field of violence against women. Our analysis involved reviewing papers published between 2018 and December 2023, which were identified through electronic database searches. Out of a total of 136 papers initially identified, we considered 71 documents. Results: This research highlights the global nature of violence against women, including psychological assessments of harm, as a socio-cultural problem and underlines the more common injuries. Conclusions: We examined how the presence of forensic experts can be beneficial in identifying and evaluating injuries, as well as reconstructing the dynamics of the events, particularly for judicial purposes.
Phosgene Inhalation in Fire-Related Deaths: A Case Report of Two Lovers Burnt in a Travelling Carousel
Callegari E., Mazzobel E., Zancaner S., Fais P., Viel G., Cecchetto G.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Fire deaths present several diagnostic challenges for the forensic examiner, the most significant of which is the identification of the cause of death and the evaluation of the morphological consequences of heat injuries in the ante-mortem and post-mortem periods. Here, we describe the case of two young lovers found dead inside a travelling carousel destroyed by a fire. Circumstantial evidence of disputes between families running the town fair raised the suspicion of intentional arson. Comparative analysis of crime scene investigation, radiological, autoptic, histological, and toxicological findings revealed signs of vitality (i.e., presence of soot deposits inside the respiratory and digestive tracts, heat damage to the respiratory mucosa) and identified fatal asphyxia from haemorrhagic pulmonary oedema as the cause of death. Since the experimental burning of plastic samples collected from a similar carousel demonstrated the significant production of phosgene, the death of the two lovers was attributed to the probable inhalation of this gas. The case presented here underlines the importance of a multidisciplinary approach of any fire-related death, providing an insight into circumstantial and forensic (autopsy, toxicological, and immunohistopathological) elements useful in raising suspicion of possible toxic gas inhalation. In the presence of high levels of PVC materials at the fire scene and pulmonary oedema at the autopsy, with no alternative causes of death, the forensic pathologist must suspect a fatal exposure to phosgene.
Fat Embolism Syndrome in a Patient with Osteogenesis Imperfecta: A Case Report
Benevento M., Carravetta F., Caterino C., Nicolì S., Ambrosi L., Ferorelli D., Solarino B.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Fat embolism syndrome (FES) can be challenging to diagnose by forensic pathologists. For the diagnosis of FES, there is no benchmark test. Postmortem diagnosis requires a full autopsy and specific ancillary examination. However, the high variability in the clinical presentation of FES represents a relevant issue, and there is no consensus on the postmortem assessment. This is the case of a 33-year-old man who died of FES one week after a car accident. He suffered multiple fractures, but was hemodynamically stable and showed no neurological changes. The patient died a few days after hospital discharge. Additionally, he had osteogenesis imperfecta type III, a genetic disorder associated with bone fragility. To the best of our knowledge, no study has assessed whether and how osteogenesis imperfecta contributes to the onset of FES. Despite the heterogeneous manifestations of FES, the present case met many of the proposed clinical and histological diagnostic criteria. Therefore, we briefly review FES diagnostic criteria, show the postmortem diagnostic workup, and discuss the hypothetical link between osteogenesis imperfecta and FES.
The Role of Coping Strategies in Children’s Repeated Suggestive Interviews
Vagni M., Giostra V.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 1,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Often in the forensic context, child victims and witnesses are interviewed several times, exposing them to suggestive questions and social pressures. The present study had the main purpose of verifying the effect of coping strategies on the levels of immediate suggestibility and on the Resistant Behavioral Responses (RBRs) of children subjected to repeated suggestive interviews. A sample of 90 children, aged between 11 and 14, were administered the two parallel Gudjonsson Suggestibility Scales (GSS2 and GSS1) a few months apart and the Coping Inventory for Stressful Situations (CISS) to detect their coping strategies. The results showed that the avoidance coping increased suggestive vulnerability and reduced resistant responses. Task-oriented coping favored responses with greater source monitoring, which allow for the rejection of misleading information. Coping strategies did not show direct effects on the management of the socioemotional aspects involved in the suggestive interaction. After the negative feedback that invites children to be more accurate, a smaller effect of the avoidance strategy was recorded, indicating how actively requesting greater source monitoring can lead children to better recognize misleading information.
Application of X-STRs for Forensic Identification in Mixed DNA Profile: A Case Report
Vacca N.I., Mongelli G., Ceccardi S., Moroni E., Agostini V.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Autosomal polymorphisms (STRs) or Y-Chromosome polymorphisms (Y-STRs) are usually used for the study and deconvolution of mixed DNA profiles in forensic genetics, accompanying data interpretation with biostatistical evaluations (e.g., RMP, RMNE, LR). Sometimes, however, some mixed DNA profiles are so complex that autosomal and Y markers are not sufficient for correct discrimination and identification. In this work is reported a robbery case in which the analysis of the polymorphic markers of the X Chromosome (X-STRs) was applied to the mixed profiles obtained from the traces. This falls outside the classic use of the X-STRs. Indeed, the aim of the authors is to encourage the usage of X-STRs not only in parental relationships, but also in pure forensic cases for interpreting complex mixed DNA profiles, since their application in case resolution could be more decisive than autosomal STRs and Y-STRs.
Use of the Investigator ESSplex SE QS Kit (QIAGEN) at Half PCR Reaction Volumes for the Analysis of Forensic Samples
Barbaro A., Falcone G., La Marca A., Barbaro A.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
PDF, doi.org, Abstract
The Investigator ESSplex SE QS Kit (Qiagen) is a next-generation polymerase chain reaction (PCR) kit that, in 60 min, amplifies 17 Short Tandem Repeat (STR) markers, including the five European Standard Set (ESS) loci (D10S1248, D12S391, D1S1656, D22S1045, D2S441), the SE33 marker, and the locus Amelogenin for sex determination. Two quality sensors (QS1 and QS2) are also co-amplified to check PCR performance. Since forensic laboratories carry out hundreds of DNA typings annually, we verified the kit’s performance using half reaction volumes with the aim of improving the number of samples that may be amplified with a single kit and consequently reducing laboratory costs. In the present study, intended as a technical note rather than internal validation, some control samples (oral swabs) with known DNA profiles and 40 real casework samples were analyzed. We observed that reducing the total reaction volume, while keeping all component ratios unaltered, yields DNA profiles comparable to those obtained using standard reaction volumes and with allele peaks higher than those with regular volumes. Using half volumes for PCR amplification enables the analysis of a larger number of samples compared to the standard protocol, thereby reducing laboratory costs without compromising the quality of the analysis.
Biobanks: Archives or Resources? Their Secondary Use for Forensic Purposes—A Systematic Review
Sguazzi G., Fasani G., Renò F., Gino S.
MDPI
Forensic Sciences, 2024, цитирований: 0,
open access Open access ,
Обзор, PDF, doi.org, Abstract
Since the biobanks’ inception in 1980, millions of human biological samples have been stored worldwide for medical research or treatment purposes. Today the secondary use of biobanks plays an increasingly important role in research projects because it allows large-scale research starting from professional collections of biospecimens and related clinical data. It would be limiting, in the “-omics” era, to not consider the enormous potential value to law enforcement of these biospecimens, where the availability of high-performance techniques makes it possible to obtain a large amount of data, even within a single session. Therefore, the quality of the sample, in addition to the associated clinical information, becomes of crucial importance to derive scientifically valid information, including for forensic research purposes. Proposing the introduction of the concept of “solidarity”, traditionally applied only to medical and research biobanks, led to public commitment to forensic medicine. Granting the forensic researcher this possibility certainly raises some questions regarding regulatory and ethical aspects of consent, privacy, confidentiality, transparency, and participant/donor trust. Since the debate has not stopped since the origin of biobanks, this review aims to explore the state of the art relating to the use of human biological material in medical biobanks for biomedical and forensic research.
Cobalt Бета
ru en